
raven2909
- November 9th, 21:49
So I mentioned that i finished reading 'Dune', and now I happen to feel like babbling on about it a bit, and I'll have a quick rant about the 80's film at the end.
I'm not sure why. I just feel like it XD
Let me start by saying that Dune is the greatest novel I have ever read, period. I had read it before now, but it was when I was like 12, I barely understood any of it. And thats not to say the ook is complicated, it has a fairly straight foward plot; a noble family is betrayed and destroyed only to try to rise again and reclaim what is thiers (that isnt a spoiler by the way, you are informed from the start there is a conspiracy to destroy them).
The reason I didnt understand alot of it as a kid is because its written so well, it's hard to explain but I think Frank Herbert might have been a genious or something. Basically the book doesnt treat us like idiots, it doesnt have an intro to explain the setting, it just jumps in and explains naturally along the way. This was a brilliant way to start a book, unlike the stupidly pointless build up some novels have. Take Harry Potter for example, its a decent series but the intro in the first book was pointless rambling, we didnt need all the information thrown at us. Think of it like starting a new job, if your boss explains to many things at once your eyes will glaze over and you'll have trouble performing your duties because you have been bombarded with them. On the other hand if your boss simple teaches you things as they come you fall into the routine far easier (strange analogy I know, but the best one I had).
It's pretty much like this the entire book, if they talk about something the reader doesnt know about, one of the characters or princess Irulan the sort of narrator (ill get to that later) explains it, and this method really works, it sells the universe really, makes me believe simply because they talk about it like its common knowledge, not with break aways or like they are explaining to a creature not of thier universe.
Princess Irulan also sheds light on events with snippets from books she writes within the story, again hard to explain, but effectivally she writes books about the occurences within the story, its really quite ingenious and draws me further into the universe.
Now for the characters, well what can I say except that this novel has probably the best characters ever thought up, smart, cunning, ruthless, compassionate. Even the villains are awesome in some way (the main villain Baron Vladimir Harkonen is still gross, but smart in his own way). My particular favorite is Gurney Hallek, a man noted for his ugliness but also his skill with music and poetry, not to mention his fighting prowess. Thats something else I should probably mention, the fight scenes. Most books can have trouble describing a good fight scene, but not dune, its described in such an elogant way that visualising it is fun and not a strain. I like Lord of the Rings and many other fantasy novels but thier battle and fight scenes suck ass, I can admit that fully.
Anyway I'm rambling a tad to much, my point is Dune is freakin awesome and everyone should read it.
Now for the movie.... It's appalling how I used to think this was a close adaptation of the book, it's not, not at all. Well thats not exactly fair, its closer than alot of movies based on books. But it has the most pointless changes, I wont spoil anything at one some point the main character takes the name Maud'dib, this is the name of a small mouse that lives in the desert, the mouse reflects wisdom and it makes sense, in the movie its apparently the name of the shadow on the moon... Which means nothing, see pointless change, there are lots of them. It has it's good points, it's miusic is great, the actors look alot like i'd expect the characters to (except for 2 or 3) and the scope of the movie is as epic as you'd expect.
Ok, I'm done rambling now :P